Research Publication: Are Ratings All the Same – A Comparative Analysis of Domestic and Global Ratings


11 May 2020

    HONG KONG, 11 May 2020. Pengyuan International has released one research report, “Are Ratings All the Same: A Comparative Analysis of Domestic and Global Ratings”.  

    This research selects samples of China’s corporate issuers and asset-backed securities (ABS) with domestic and global credit ratings to compare and analyse the differences in the two rating scales and the reasons behind such differences. Our findings show that:

    For corporate issuers, the ratings of domestic CRAs are 8.69 notches higher on average than those of global CRAs. Compared with domestic ratings, global ratings demonstrate more significant variations in different firm types and industries, and a better discriminatory power. The results of the Receiver Operating Characteristics (ROC) curve analyses show that global ratings are superior to domestic ratings in terms of ranking power for credit risks, but domestic ratings still provide valuable information on credit risks.

    Domestic and global ratings on asset-backed securities (ABS) products are relatively similar, with the former marginally higher than the latter by around two notches. Senior tranches and ABS with standardised underlying assets demonstrate even smaller differences between domestic and global ratings. We believe that for ABS products, the rating symbols in domestic and global rating scales represent relatively similar creditworthiness compared to the ratings for corporate issuers. In addition, both domestic and global rating agencies adopt quantitative-based rating methodologies for ABS products, leaving the rating results more objective and comparable.

    Domestic ratings demonstrate a lack of consistency and comparability across various industries and products. For instance, as an indicator of credit quality, the credit spreads differ markedly for corporates with the same domestic credit ratings in the property sector and non-bank financial institutions. In addition, corporates and financial institutions have far higher domestic ratings than global ratings, but Credit ABS have relatively similar ratings between their domestic and global ratings. This means that even if Credit ABS have the same domestic credit ratings as some corporate issuers, their credit risks may be widely different from each other.

    Assigning domestic and global ratings simultaneously to an issuer or bond will facilitate the research and investment activities for both onshore and offshore investors. Firstly, global ratings provide onshore investors with a more differentiated credit-risk ranking. China’s bond market needs a more granular ranking of credit risks to improve credit pricing and assist investors in decision-making. In addition, foreign investors are more familiar with the global rating scale, which can provide a useful reference and guidance for their investments in China’s bond market. On the other hand, the domestic-rating scale conforms to the ecosystem and practices in China’s domestic bond market. After all, investment guidelines and risk-management systems for domestic investors are constructed on the basis of domestic rating scales.

    ANALYST CONTACTS
    Primary Analyst                                                              
    Ke Chen, PhD                                                                               
    +852 3615 8316                                                                      
    ke.chen@pyrating.com                      
    Secondary Analyst
    Xi Li
    +86 755 8287 2106
    xi.li@pyrating.com
    Committee Chair
    Tong Tang
    +852 3615 8278
    tony.tang@pyrating.com
    MEDIA ENQUIRIES 
    Charley Lui  
    +852 3615 8296
    charley.lui@pyrating.com
    RATING SERVICES ENQUIRIES
    Gloria Song
    +852 3615 8324
    gloria.song@pyrating.com
    Additional information is available on www.pyrating.com

    *******************************************************************
    DISCLAIMER

    Pengyuan Credit Rating (Hong Kong) Company Ltd (“Pengyuan International”, “Pengyuan”, “the Company”) prepares various credit research and related commentary (collectively “research”) in compliance with the established internal process. The Company reserves the right to amend, change, remove, publish any information on its website without prior notice and at its sole discretion.

    The research is subject to disclaimers and limitations. RESEARCH AND CREDIT RATINGS ARE NOT FINANCIAL OR INVESTMENT ADVICE AND MUST NOT BE CONSIDERED AS A RECOMMENDATION TO BUY, SELL OR HOLD ANY SECURITIES AND DO NOT ADDRESS/REFLECT MARKET VALUE OF ANY SECURITIES. USERS OF RESEARCH AND CREDIT RATINGS ARE EXPECTED TO BE TRAINED FOR INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF INVESTMENT AND BUSINESS DECISIONS.

    This research is based solely on the public data and information available to the authors at the time of publication of this research. For the purpose of this research, the Company obtains sufficient quality factual information from public sources believed by the Company to be reliable and accurate. The Company does not perform an audit and undertakes no duty of due diligence or third-party verification of any information it uses in the research. The Company is not responsible for any omissions, errors or inconsistencies of the public information used in the research.

    NO WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS TO THE ACCURACY, TIMELINESS OR COMPLETENESS OF ANY INFORMATION GIVEN OR MADE BY THE COMPANY IN ANY FORM OR MANNER. In no event shall the Company, its directors, shareholders, employees, representatives be liable to any party for any damages, expenses, fees, or losses in connection with any use of the information published by the Company.

    This research focuses on observing trends from the credit markets. This research has not been made available to any issuer prior its distribution to the public. The Company does not receive compensation for its research.

    The Company reserves the right to disseminate its research through its website, the Company’s social media pages and authorised third parties. No content published by the Company may be modified, reproduced, transferred, distributed or reverse engineered in any form by any means without the prior written consent of the Company.

    The Company’s research is not indented for distribution to, or use by, any person in a jurisdiction where such usage would infringe the law. If in doubt, please consult the relevant regulatory body or professional advisor and ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations.

    In the event of any dispute arising out of or in relation to our research, the Company shall have absolute discretion in all matters relating to resolving the dispute, including but not limited to the interpretation of disclaimers and policies.

    Copyright © 2020 by Pengyuan Credit Rating (Hong Kong) Company Ltd. All rights reserved.