Research Publication: Seeing Through Frosted Glass: Assessing Chinese Local Governments’ Creditworthiness


29 Jun 2020

    HONG KONG, 29 June 2020. Pengyuan International has today published a research report, “Seeing Through Frosted Glass: Assessing Chinese Local Governments’ Creditworthiness”.

    The report is aimed at giving a profound insight in the creditworthiness of different level local governments (LG) in China by introducing the governing structure of the country, demonstrating the fiscal and debt features of the LGs, and delivering some valuable information of the credit statues of the LGs. The key takeaways from this report are as follows:

    We believe it is necessary to employ a top-down rating approach to assess Chinese local governments’ credit profiles as we believe it better reflects with the nation’s vertically integrated governing structure.

    In our opinion, the higher the level of an LG, the more power it possesses to shape intra-governmental relations, mobilise external financial resources and the more state-owned assets and enterprises it may control. Higher-Level LGs (HLG), such as at provincial level, should have better creditworthiness than a municipal level LG and so forth. The political influence of each provincial region has shifted overtime, which can shed light on national strategies. We believe the political influence of the region of Xinjiang, the municipality of Chongqing and the province of Hainan has gradually increased over the past two decades.

    LGs’ fiscal revenue growth has been muted in recent years. They have started feeling this deficit and Covid-19 could make things worse.

    In our view, the main revenue generators of LGs like the taxes, non-tax fees and land sales proceeds have been curbed by the central government’s proactive fiscal strategy and real estate policies. All the while, expenditures have remained strong so deficits have surged and to counter Covid-19’s impact, we expect LGs will experience even heavier deficits in 2020 than ever before.

    LGs’ debts have expanded rapidly with the direct debt growth outpacing hidden debt.

    Seeing their fiscal imbalances exacerbated, LGs have resorted to borrowing to prop up their expenses and so the whole debt pile has swollen. Hidden debt is still the bulk of LG’s debts but has been reined in by the central government’s stringent hand. On the other hand, however, direct debt (LG bonds) has surged and the sector has been in the spotlight in the domestic bond market in recent years. LG Bonds accounted for 23% of the total outstanding domestic bonds at the end of May 2020 and this is expected to continue growing in coming years.

    Based on our assessment, provincial-level governments’ credit ratings should be no lower than 3 notches below that of the sovereign.

    We believe the central government will keep provincial level governments’ creditworthiness in close range to its own but that does not mean provincial-level governments’ creditworthiness will be identical. While some gaps exist among provincial LGs in facets such as local economy, budgetary performance, debt burden and liquidity so far, all provincial LGs have managed to maintain strong credit profiles.

    The difference in creditworthiness among prefecture-level city LGs can be huge and the gap is even wider among lower district and county LGs.

    Provincial capitals and cities with independent planning (CWIP) boast stronger credit profiles among the prefecture-level cities due to their unique economic and political status. We estimate the prefecture-level LGs in eastern China by and large have better budgetary strength than the LGs in other parts of the country and the LGs in the west have seen greater divergence in their performances relating to revenue and debt.

    ANALYST CONTACTS

    Jameson Zuo

    +852 3615 8341

    jameson.zuo@pyrating.com

    Lisa Hu

    +86 755 8321 0225

    li.hu@pyrating.com

    Tony Tang

    +852 3615 8278

    tony.tang@pyrating.com

    Committee Chair

    Tony Tang

    +852 3615 8278

    tony.tang@pyrating.com

    MEDIA ENQUIRIES 

    Ms. Charley Lui 

    Direct+852 3615 8296

    charley.lui@pyrating.com

    RATING SERVICES ENQUIRIES

    Ms. Gloria Song

    Direct+852 3615 8324

    gloria.song@pyrating.com

    Date of Relevant Rating Committee: 22-Jun-2020

    Additional information is available on www.pyrating.com

    ***********************************************

    DISCLAIMER

    Pengyuan Credit Rating (Hong Kong) Company Ltd (“Pengyuan International”, “Pengyuan”, “the Company”) prepares various credit research and related commentary (collectively “research”) in compliance with the established internal process. The Company reserves the right to amend, change, remove, publish any information on its website without prior notice and at its sole discretion.
    The research is subject to disclaimers and limitations. RESEARCH AND CREDIT RATINGS ARE NOT FINANCIAL OR INVESTMENT ADVICE AND MUST NOT BE CONSIDERED AS A RECOMMENDATION TO BUY, SELL OR HOLD ANY SECURITIES AND DO NOT ADDRESS/REFLECT MARKET VALUE OF ANY SECURITIES. USERS OF RESEARCH AND CREDIT RATINGS ARE EXPECTED TO BE TRAINED FOR INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENT OF INVESTMENT AND BUSINESS DECISIONS.
    This research is based solely on the public data and information available to the authors at the time of publication of this research. For the purpose of this research, the Company obtains sufficient quality factual information from public sources believed by the Company to be reliable and accurate. The Company does not perform an audit and undertakes no duty of due diligence or third-party verification of any information it uses in the research. The Company is not responsible for any omissions, errors or inconsistencies of the public information used in the research.
    NO WARRANTY, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, AS TO THE ACCURACY, TIMELINESS OR COMPLETENESS OF ANY INFORMATION GIVEN OR MADE BY THE COMPANY IN ANY FORM OR MANNER. In no event shall the Company, its directors, shareholders, employees, representatives be liable to any party for any damages, expenses, fees, or losses in connection with any use of the information published by the Company.
    This research focuses on observing trends from the credit markets. This research has not been made available to any issuer prior its distribution to the public. The Company does not receive compensation for its research.
    The Company reserves the right to disseminate its research through its website, the Company’s social media pages and authorised third parties. No content published by the Company may be modified, reproduced, transferred, distributed or reverse engineered in any form by any means without the prior written consent of the Company.
    The Company’s research is not indented for distribution to, or use by, any person in a jurisdiction where such usage would infringe the law. If in doubt, please consult the relevant regulatory body or professional advisor and ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations.
    In the event of any dispute arising out of or in relation to our research, the Company shall have absolute discretion in all matters relating to resolving the dispute, including but not limited to the interpretation of disclaimers and policies.
    Copyright © 2020 by Pengyuan Credit Rating (Hong Kong) Company Ltd. All rights reserved.